Life cycle assessment of incandescent and compact fluorescent lightbulbs

Concerned about the potential environmental impacts of the products it promotes and wishing to keep customers wellinformed, Hydro-Québec asked the CIRAIG to undertake a comparative life cycle assessment of incandescent and compact fluorescent lightbulbs (CFLs).

Concerned about the potential environmental impacts of the products it promotes and wishing to keep customers wellinformed, Hydro-Québec asked the International Reference Centre for the Life Cycle of Products, Processes and Services (CIRAIG) to undertake a comparative life cycle assessment of incandescent and compact fluorescent lightbulbs (CFLs). Results For households that heat with electricity The use of energy-efficient CFLs remains the most environmentally sound option at all times, for all the aspects analyzed. For households that heat with natural gas or oil
  • Outside of heating season, the use of energy-efficient CFLs is the most environmentally sound option.
  • During heating season, incandescent lightbulbs seem to be a better option since they give off heat. However, CFLs remain the best choice for two reasons: the energy savings achieved and, consequently, the potential to use Québec’s clean energy to replace energy from polluting sources.
Mercury in CFLs CFLs pose no significant threat to human health or the environment. The amount of mercury in CFLs is so small (less than 20% of the amount in a watch battery) that waste management accounts for only 1% of the overall environmental impacts in the life cycle. https://www.hydroquebec.com/data/developpement-durable/pdf/ACV-ampoules-resume-de-letude.pdf

In collaboration with

Similar projects

Biomass energy, or bioenergy, is energy produced from renewable biomass, for which the assessment of environmental impacts through life cycle assessment (LCA) presents a number of challenges, in particular methodological ones. The general objectives of this study are to analyze current practices for carrying out LCAs of biomass energy, and to provide recommendations on current and future best practices.

Food choices have a significant climate impact, which can be unknown to the public. The CIRAIG, commissioned by Polytechnique Montréal, has been tasked with calculating the climate-warming impact of the menus offered by the cafeteria, aiming to enable students to understand the impact of their meals and change their eating habits to reduce it.

Subscribe to our newsletter !