Small-scale distributed electric power generation

Hydro-Québec mandated CIRAIG’s International Life Cycle Chair to analyze and compare different small-scale distributed electricity generation options, using LCA methodology. Five systems were compared: three types of small turbines and two types of photovoltaic solar panels. The electricity generated by these systems was also compared to the electricity supplied by Hydro-Québec’s network.


  • Kilowatthours supplied by Hydro-Québec’s network outperformed those generated by each of the five distributed electricity generation systems studied, based on indicators for Human health, Climate change, Resources, Aquatic acidification and Aquatic eutrophication. However, results for the Quality of ecosystems indicator were inconclusive.
  • In terms of environmental impact of the five distributed electricity generation systems, the 30 kW wind turbine outperformed the others for indicators for Climate change, Resources, and Aquatic eutrophication. The photovoltaic panels ranked first in the indicator of Human health. The indicators Quality of ecosystems and Aquatic acidification did not demonstrate a clear advantage for either the 30 kW wind turbine or the photovoltaic panels.

In collaboration with

Similar projects

Open source Input-Output LCA model and tool to estimate life cycle impacts of products and services

Biomass energy, or bioenergy, is energy produced from renewable biomass, for which the assessment of environmental impacts through life cycle assessment (LCA) presents a number of challenges, in particular methodological ones. The general objectives of this study are to analyze current practices for carrying out LCAs of biomass energy, and to provide recommendations on current and future best practices.

Food choices have a significant climate impact, which can be unknown to the public. The CIRAIG, commissioned by Polytechnique Montréal, has been tasked with calculating the climate-warming impact of the menus offered by the cafeteria, aiming to enable students to understand the impact of their meals and change their eating habits to reduce it.

Subscribe to our newsletter !